Couple · Review
We're Not Really Strangers Couples Edition: An Honest Review for New-Parent Couples
Affiliate-link notice. This page contains affiliate links to Amazon and other retailers. If you click a link and buy something, Babbycare may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we'd put in our own house. Full disclosure here.
Six of the eight new-parent couples we've talked to honestly about their first year credit a deck of conversation cards with the night they remembered why they liked each other. The most common deck is this one: We're Not Really Strangers Couples Edition. We bought it, played through it, and watched what happened to friends who borrowed ours.
The short version: it's not a magic relationship-saver — no $25 product is. It is a way to get past the parts of a conversation that you and your partner have already had a hundred times, into the parts you haven't. For couples 1-7 years in who have stopped asking each other anything new, that's the unlock that's worth the price.
What's in the box
A black tuck-box, about the size of a Bicycle deck, holding 150 cards split across three levels and one wildcard category. The cards are matte black with white text, slightly heavier stock than playing cards, no instruction booklet beyond what's printed on the first card of each level.
- Level 1 — Perception. 50 cards. Lightweight by intent. "What's something I do that always makes you smile?" "What's the first thing you noticed about me?" "What is one of your earliest childhood memories?" The point is rhythm — getting the two of you talking before the harder cards land.
- Level 2 — Connection. 50 cards. The middle is where most of the work happens. "What part of our relationship do you think we don't talk about enough?" "When was the last time you felt truly seen by me?" "What is your love language and is it being met right now?" These are the cards that turn a 30-minute card-game-night into a 90-minute slow conversation.
- Level 3 — Reflection. 50 cards. The "we are an actual couple now and we have actual things to say" section. This is where some couples close the deck and go to bed grateful and some couples stay up arguing. It's also where we'd recommend you stop the first time and pick this back up after a week of letting it sit.
- Wildcard. Scattered through the levels — physical-action cards (touch my hand, look at me without breaking eye contact for 30 seconds, kiss me on the forehead). These break the pattern and matter more than they sound like they would on the box.
What works
- + Levels are calibrated — you genuinely warm up before the hard questions land
- + Cards are open-ended in a way that makes it hard to give the same answer twice
- + Wildcard physical-action cards reset the conversation when it gets too verbal
- + $25 is fair for what it actually does — most of our friends say the price was the cheapest part of any couple's-therapy-adjacent thing they've paid for
- + The format works for couples who would never go to actual therapy together
What doesn't
- − Level 3 is too much for the first night with the deck — pace yourself or you'll wreck a perfectly fine evening
- − It is not a substitute for therapy when there are real underlying issues — the deck reveals; it does not repair
- − Some of the Level 1 cards feel like dating-app prompts and may not move couples 5+ years in (skip these)
- − Cards mix pronouns and assume monogamy in some prompts — minor, but worth noting
- − If your relationship is currently in a fight cycle, the deck will feel weaponized — wait for a calmer night
What new-parent couples specifically should know
Most reviews of this deck are written by couples who used it on a normal Friday with no childcare obligations. The new-parent context is different in three ways that matter:
1. The window is shorter than you remember
Pre-baby, we'd sit down with something like this and play three hours. Post-baby, you've got the slot between baby's bedtime (around 7-8 p.m.) and the dream feed (around 10-11 p.m.) — call it 90 minutes. That is one Level, generously. Plan for the deck to take five sessions over two months, not one Friday night. We did Level 1 the first night, took a week off, did half of Level 2 the next time, etc.
2. The "what's changed about us" prompts hit harder
Several Level 2 cards ask about how the relationship has changed. For couples without kids, those land as reflective. For new-parent couples, they land as hot. "What part of how we are now do you miss?" is a different question at year three of marriage than at month nine of being parents to a small human. Be ready for that.
What worked for us: not pretending the answer was nothing. Both of us had things to say about what was different — the ease of evenings, the spontaneity, the not-knowing-what-the- other-was-thinking-and-having-time-to-find-out — and saying them out loud to each other, without an immediate "but I love being parents and I wouldn't change it" qualifier, was itself the work.
3. Skip the specific cards that don't fit your stage
Some cards are calibrated to early dating (questions about meeting each other's families, first impressions, etc.). At year four with a small human, those are nostalgia at best and irrelevant at worst. Pull them out before you start; don't make yourselves answer every card. The deck is a starting point, not a script.
How it compares to alternatives
The conversation-card category has gotten crowded. The decks we've actually played through, ranked for new-parent couples specifically:
WNRS Couples Edition vs. Esther Perel's "Where Should We Begin?" deck
Esther Perel's deck is more therapeutic in design — every card has Perel's clinical framing in mind. It is the right deck for couples who are trying to repair something specific. WNRS is the right deck for couples who are trying to remember each other. Different jobs. If we had to pick one for a new-parent couple not currently in therapy, we'd pick WNRS — it's lower-stakes and the wins come faster. If we were already seeing a couples therapist, we'd pick Perel's because the language meshes with what's happening in the sessions.
WNRS Couples Edition vs. The And (Couples Edition)
The And (also $25) is similar in format with a slightly more serious tone. It's the better choice for couples 7+ years in or for couples doing the deck in tandem with therapy. WNRS is more playful, which is actually the right thing for an exhausted couple who needs to laugh first.
WNRS Couples Edition vs. Best Self Co. Intimacy Deck
Best Self's deck is more sex-and-physical-intimacy-focused. WNRS is broader — emotional, historical, future-thinking. For new-parent couples who haven't had sex in three months, WNRS is the gentler entry point; Best Self is the next deck after that, when you're ready to be specific about the physical side again. We have a separate guide to that side of things.
Who this is not for
- Couples in active conflict. If you're currently in the bad pattern, the cards will feel like ammunition. Wait until things are calm and you're both actually curious about each other.
- Couples expecting therapy in a box. The deck is a conversation starter, not a healing protocol. If your relationship needs repair, see a real therapist. WNRS won't get you there alone.
- Brand-new couples. The Level 3 cards assume shared history. If you've been together less than a year, you'll find them too heavy or too generic.
- People who hate cards / forced prompts. If your reaction to a written prompt is "I wouldn't say that out loud," the deck will feel performative. That's a legit preference, not a flaw.
How to actually do it (what worked for us)
- Pick a night when neither of you is mid-fight or mid-deadline. A weeknight, after baby's bedtime, with the dishes already done. Not date-night-from-hell with expectations.
- Start with two glasses of water and a snack. Sounds dumb. Solves a real problem — sleep-deprived people running on caffeine cannot stay present for an hour of intentional conversation. Hydration and a slow snack changes the math.
- Read each card out loud, then both think for a beat before answering. Don't bounce. The point is what you actually think, not what your default reflex says.
- Take turns reading. Whoever reads, the other person answers first. Don't let the same person ask three in a row.
- Stop before you're tired. Twenty cards is a lot. If you get through ten and you're both still thinking, leave the rest for next time. The fatigued version of either of you will not produce the conversation you actually want.
- Don't talk about the cards afterward like a debrief. The conversation is the conversation. A meta-conversation about it the next morning ("what did you think about my answer to card 14") tends to flatten what was real.
Verdict
Buy it. If you and your partner are in the boat where most new-parent couples are — tired, slightly bored of each other in a way that scares you both, slightly embarrassed to ask "what are you actually thinking lately" without a pretext — this is the pretext. $25 buys you several nights of slower conversation than you've been having, and a deck you can come back to in year five and year eight. We'd buy it again. Most of the couples we know who borrowed ours bought their own.
Check current price on Amazon →